Decline of the Dharma

For other meanings of "Latter Days", see Latter Days (disambiguation). For other uses of Three Ages, see Three Ages (disambiguation).

The Decline of the Dharma or Ages of the Dharma, refers to traditional Buddhist accounts of how the Buddhist religion and the Buddha's teaching (Dharma) is believed to decline throughout history. It constitutes a key aspect of Buddhist eschatology and provides a cyclical model of history, beginning with a virtuous age where spiritual practice is very fruitful and ending with an age of strife, in which Buddhism is eventually totally forgotten. Buddhist accounts of this process culminate in the eventual arrival of a new Buddha, Maitreya.

There are various accounts of this process of Dharma decline, which begins with Shakyamuni Buddha's death and continues throughout the generations as society and its knowledge of the Buddha's teachings decline over the centuries.

Ages of the Dharma

Further information: Dharma § Buddhism

There are different accounts of the decline of the Buddha's teaching (Buddha Dharma), i.e. Buddhism. These Buddhist accounts of longue durée history and temporal cosmology always assumes a cyclical pattern of virtue and decline. In degenerate times, the current Buddha's teachings fall into disregard and are forgotten. In virtuous times a new Buddha will at some point (usually considered to be millions of years in the future) be born to ensure the continuity of Buddhism.

The teaching of the decline of the Dharma is found in early Buddhist sources. References to the decline of the Dharma over time can also be found Mahayana sutras, including the Diamond Sutra and the Lotus Sutra.

Mahayanist and Nikaya (non-Mahayanist) sources all agree that our current time period is now on the downward slope of degeneration and that only after a period of strife and disaster will the cycle reverse to a period of gradual improvements. Different authors and traditions offer varying accounts of the timeline of decline.

Cakkavatti Sutta

Detail of a sculpted railing at Phanigiri depicting a Chakravartin

One of the earliest sources which contain a Buddhist discussion of historical decline is found in the Cakkavatti-Sīhanāda Sutta (Digha Nikaya 26) of the Pāli Canon (as well as in various parallel sources in other canons, like Dīrghāgama sutra number 6). The sutta recounts the story of a legendary universal monarch (cakkavatti) who lived far in the past. This king governed righteously and upheld the Dhamma, ensuring peace and prosperity. Over time, successive kings neglect the Dharmic principles and fail to uphold the Dhamma. They become greedy, unjust, and self-serving. Over time, societal values erode, leading to widespread poverty, crime, and moral decay. With each generation, human lifespan diminishes, reflecting the decline of moral and spiritual qualities. The sutta also describes how lifespan decreases from 80,000 years (when the wheel turning king ruled) to as little as 10 years during the peak of societal degeneration. In this bleak period, violence and lawlessness prevail, and society becomes increasingly fragmented and chaotic and people take refuge in caves to escape the fighting.

The sutta then describes a turning point in history. A few individuals retreat from the chaos, renouncing violence and embracing moral conduct. Their example inspires others to change, gradually restoring societal harmony. As moral conduct improves, human lifespan begins to increase again, and the conditions for prosperity and peace are reestablished by a new wheel turning king called Sankha. Eventually, the Buddha Metteyya (Maitreya) arrives. He is the next Buddha after Shakyamuni, who will teach the Dhamma during a time of renewal. Under Metteyya’s guidance, people will again follow the path of virtue and wisdom, achieving liberation.

Theravada sources

The Vinaya (Monastic Rule) of the Theravada school (Cullavagga X, 1,6.) claims that the true Dharma will only last for 500 years. It states that the true Dharma (saddhamma) would have lasted longer (1000 years) if not for the admission of women into the monastic sangha as bhikkunis. This claim also appears in the texts belonging to other Sthavira schools, including the Dharmaguptaka, Sarvastivada, and Mahisasaka schools but it does not appear in any single text surviving from the Mahasamghika school. As Nattier writers "Modern scholars have generally been reluctant to accept this pronouncement as representing the words of the Buddha, finding it more reasonable to assume that it emerged in misogynist circles sometime well after the Buddha's death." She also argues that since the claim is not found in any Mahasamghika works, this suggests the claim developed somewhat after the first schism.

The standard view in the Theravada school is a timetable of decline lasting five thousand years. This schema was first taught in the works of the fifth century commentator Buddhaghosa. This time table is divided into five one thousand year periods. In each period, there is the disappearance of certain elements of the Dharma:

1. Disappearance of attainments (Pali: adhigama): In the first one thousand years, people gradually lose the ability to attain all the four stages of enlightenment.
2. Disappearance of the method (patipatti): In this period people gradually stop practicing meditation and keeping precepts properly.
3. Disappearance of learning (pariyatti): Gradually, the scriptures begin to be lost until all are lost at the end of this period.
4. Disappearance of signs (nimitta): monks abandon the robe and enter into secular life.
5. Disappearance of relies (dhatu): gradually the relics of the Buddha stop being worshiped and are lost.

Abhidharma

The Buddhist scholastic literature of the Abhidharma traditions provide more elaborate accounts of the various historical ages of the Dharma. The most influential such Abhidharma account in the northern tradition is found in Vasubandhu's Abhidharmakośabhāṣya. The text divides the cosmological history of the universe into four kalpas (a huge span of time), which is further divided into twenty antarakalpas (sub-eons). Each antarakalpa during the last kalpa of the universe is said to oscillate between periods of social and ethical growth and decline. The zenith of goodness is a time when human beings live to be 80,000 years and during the nadir, lifespans have shrunk to 10 years. During the zenith of moral progress, there is peace and abundance, while the at the end, there is only war. This then oscillates back to a time of gradual improvement until a new Buddha arrives, and the cycle begins again.

In Mahayana sources

Various Mahayana Sutras contain different accounts of the ages of the Dharma and the periods of Dharma decline. Both the Diamond Sutra and the Lotus sutra contain mentions of a period of decline in the future, though these sutras do not provide explicit accounts of this idea. In one passage from the Diamond Sutra, Subhuti asks the Buddha if there will be any beings who will understand the teaching of the sutra "in the future time, in the latter age, in the latter period, in the latter five hundred years, when the True Dharma is in the process of decay." Similarly, the Lotus Sutra also mentions a period "after the Tathagata's paranirvana, in the latter age, in the latter period, in the latter five hundred years."

According to Edward Conze, the term "the last five hundred years" (paścimāyāṃ pañcaśatyām in Sanskrit) seems to assume a series of five-hundred-year periods, of which the "last five hundred years" is an age of decline. However, Nattier argues that this term was likely just referring to the five hundred years after the Buddha's final nirvana (physical death).

Some sutras contain different time tables however, the Mahayana Nirvana Sutra for example, mentions a period of seven hundred years, not five hundred. The passage states: "After seven hundred years have passed since my death, the True Dharma will be broken, decayed, and brought to ruin by sinful Mara." The sutra goes on to explain how even in the time of decline and decandence, the Buddhist community will continue to exist for some time, even if many monks won't be living in the traditional way. The real danger of this period, according to the Nirvana Sutra, is that many people will reject the Mahayana sutras and the eternity of the Buddha, teaching that his death was final and that he was a mere mortal.

Other sutras mention a time of one thousand years. The Bhadrakalpika-sutra for example, states "The true Dharma (saddharma) will last for five hundred years, and likewise the semblace of the true Dharma (saddharma-pratirūpaka)." This one thousand year timetable is also found in other sources like the Dazhidulun. Still other sutras, like the Candragarbha Sutra of the Great Collection, has a period of 1,500 years, with the true Dharma lasting for 500 years and the age of the "semblance of the true dharma" (saddharma-pratirupaka) lasting for a thousand years.

The Candragarbha Sutra (CH: Yuezangfen 月藏分, Moon Treasury Section) of the Mahāsaṃnipāta Sūtra is a key source for the doctrine of Dharma decline. There are different editions of this text. One of these provides a different schema of five five-hundred year periods (五五百歳, Chinese: wǔ wǔ bǎi sùi; Japanese: go no gohyaku sai), each of which is less ideal for practicing Buddhism than the last. This schema, which covers a span of 2,500 years was also very influential in East Asian Buddhism and it was widely quoted and relied upon by Chinese and Japanese authors.

These five ages are:

1. The true Dharma age, in which Buddhist believers resolutely cultivate wisdom and achieve liberation
2. The age in which Buddhists can resolutely practice meditation,
3. The age in which Buddhists resolutely study, recite, listen to and learn the teachings
4. The age in which Buddhists focus on building temples, stupas and undertake repentance,
5. The age of decline, in which the Dharma has diminished and believers quarrel with each other.

The fifth and last age of decline is one in which the people would be incapable of practicing the Buddha's Dharma. Eventually the Buddhist teachings would be totally lost, leading to the need for a new Buddha to be born in the world. This time period would also be characterized by unrest, strife, famine, and natural disasters.

Three ages in East Asian Buddhism

In East Asian Buddhism, the most influential schema used to explain the decline of the Dharma is one of three ages of Dharma. This schema was formulated by Chinese authors out of the various different accounts found in the sutras and is not found in any specific Mahayana sutra in a systematic fashion. These three divisions of time following Buddha's passing are:

1. Age of the Right Dharma (Chinese: 正法; pinyin: zhèng fǎ; Japanese: shōbō, Sanskrit: saddharma-kāla), also known as Former Period of the Dharma. This refers to the first thousand years (or 500 years depending on the source) during which the Buddha's disciples are able to uphold the Buddha's teachings and it is possible to attain enlightenment;
2. Age of the Semblance Dharma (Chinese: 像法; pinyin: xiàng fǎ; Japanese: zōhō, Sanskrit: saddharma-pratirūpaka-kāla), also known as Middle Period of the Dharma. This is the second thousand years (or 500 years), which only "resembles" true Dharma. It is a "reflection" (pratirūpaka) of the right Dharma. A few people might be able to attain enlightenment during this time, but most people just follow the forms of the religion.
3. Last Age of the Dharma (Chinese: 末法; pinyin: mò fǎ; Japanese: mappō) or Final Age (末世 mo-shi, Sanskrit: paścima-kāla), which is to last for 10,000 years during which the Dharma declines. At this time, the spiritual capacities of human beings is at a low point and traditional religious practices lose their effectiveness.

There is a passage from the Mahayana-abhisamaya-sutra (Taisho no. 839) which contains the idea of three ages used together in one passage which states: "The Tathagata manifests himself and descends from the Tusita Heaven to uphold the entire True Dharma (zhèng fǎ), the entire Semblance Dharma (xiàng fǎ), and the entire Final Dharma (mò fǎ)." However, as Nattier notes, this sutra was translated after the concept of the three ages was already adopted into Chinese Buddhism, so it cannot be the main source of the idea.

Nanyue Huisi (515-577), the third Patriarch of the Tiantai school, was the first Chinese author to present the three ages schema.

In Tibetan Buddhism

Tibetan Buddhism generally follows a four age model, similar to the Hindu concept of the four yugas. The first is a virtuous age, and the following ages progressively decline in terms of the five degenerations: lifespans decrease, defilements increase, beings (become difficult to teach), times (wars and famines and other disasters increase), views (false beliefs proliferate).

The four ages in this schema are:

1. The age of completeness, a time of mostly virtue and goodness.
2. The age of three-quarters, in which the degenerations begin
3. The age of two-quarters, in which the degenerations increase further.
4. The age of strife or the degenerate age, a time in which the degenerations become the worst, and murder and other forms of evil become very common.

Tibetan Buddhist views are also informed by the Buddhist tantric literature. The Kalacakra tantra is an influential Buddhist tantra which contains an extensive prophecy of the future decline and revival of the Dharma.

Causes

Buddhist sources contain numerous accounts of the reasons and causes for the degeneration of the Dharma. Some of these causes are caused by external forces, such as invasions and persecution by non-buddhists. Other accounts place the blame on Buddhists, who weaken the religion from within either due to having heretical views, or due to laxity in conduct and meditation, carelessness or other moral failings.

A classic passage comes from the Saṃyutta Nikāya, which states:

There are five dharmas of decline that are conducive to the corruption and disappearance of the True Dharma. Which five? It is when monks, nuns, laymen, and laywomen are irreverent and unruly toward the teacher (sat-thar, i.e., the Buddha), are irreverent and unruly toward the Dharma, are irreverent and unruly toward the sangha, are irreverent and unruly toward the training (sikkha), and are irreverent and unruly toward meditational absorption (samadhi).

Other passages mention quarrels and sectarian divisions within the sangha as a major element of Dharma decline, as well as the development of a false or "counterfeit" Dharma. Regarding actions of non-Buddhists, most sources mention foreign invaders and also the actions of powerful states as causes for the decline of the Dharma. As to the issue of state regulation, the Humane Kings Sutra mentions that state restrictions on monastic ordinations, stupa building and the crafting of images will lead to further decline.

Responses to the age of decline

While the teaching of the decline of the Dharma is found in all Buddhist traditions, they don't all agree on what to do about it. Different traditions interpret and respond to this teaching in various ways. Nattier divides the main responses into two main approaches:

1. a conservative approach which focuses on redoubling our efforts to preserve the teachings and to try harder to follow the traditional Buddhist practices. This approach is the standard one in Theravada Buddhism and in Indo-Tibetan Buddhism. It was also adopted by some East Asian traditions and authors.
2. the opposite response, which sees most or all traditional Buddhist practices as unsuitable for the current age of decline. This approach often entails a kind of Buddhist "dispensationalism" which argues that since we find ourselves is an unprecedented age, one should focus on special practices which are specifically useful for this time. This is the position of Chinese Pure Land authors like Daochuo and Japanese figures like Hōnen and Nichiren.

East Asian Buddhism

The ages of Dharma is an important teaching in East Asian Mahayana. It was a key teaching for several forms of early Chinese Buddhism, such as for the now defunct Three Stages school. This teaching was also important in the Lotus Sutra schools who believe that different Buddhist teachings are skillful and useful in each period due to the different capacities of the people living in different ages. Since the time of Nanyue Huisi (515-577), the idea of Dharma decline has been a part of the Tiantai school. Saichō, the Japanese founder of Tendai (the Japanese branch of Tiantai), also wrote about the idea of Dharma decline (Jp: mappō), explaining how certain Tendai teachings were well suited for this time. In particular, Saichō argued that monks should retreat to the mountains to meditate. Drawing on passages in the Lotus Sutra which mention how it will be taught during the time of decline, Saichō also argued that his time (which he held was close to the arrival of the age of decline) was just the right time for the Tendai Lotus teaching. As he writes in his Shugo kokkaisho:

Now men's faculties have all changed. There is no one with Hinayana faculties. The Period of the True and of the Imitated Dharma have almost passed, and the age of mappo is extremely near. Now is the time for those with faculties suitable for the Lotus One-vehicle teaching.

Saichō also argued that during this time it would become more and more difficult to keep the monastic Vinaya precepts and eventually the monastic precepts would disappear. He saw the corruption of the monks at the capital of Nara as an example of the degeneration of the Dharma. As such, he focused on the bodhisattva precepts instead of on the Vinaya. Saichō also criticized the state bureaucracy which controlled the Buddhist schools in Japan at the time as another contributor to Dharma decline.

The doctrine of Dharma decline is also central to Pure Land Buddhism. Pure land Buddhists believe that we are now in the latter age of "degenerate Dharma", which means that the Buddhist paths based on self-effort, the "path of sages" which relies on discipline and meditation, are no longer effective or useful for most people. Pure Land followers therefore attempt to attain rebirth into the pure land of Amitābha, where they can practice the Dharma more readily.

The first figure to teach the Pure Land view of the age of Dharma decline was patriarch Daochuo (562–645), who writes:

That is why it is stated in the Yuezang section of the Ta-chi ching (大集月藏經): ‘In our age of Dharma decline, even though countless sentient beings may cultivate the path through practice, not one will attain it.’ This age now is the era of Dharma decline, and a corrupted world of the five defilements is now manifest. The gate to the Pure Land is the only path by which people may reach [enlightenment].

Following Daochuo, other Pure Land authors like Shandao, adopted this idea, arguing that only the Pure Land Dharma gate was efficacious, since it relied on the other-power of Buddha Amitabha's past vows. Other paths relied on self-power, and thus could no longer be effective in the age of degeneration. During the Kamakura Period (1185 to 1333), several Japanese Buddhist figures saw the strife and corruption of this historical period as a sign of the coming of the age of decline. Much of Japanese Buddhism during this period is concerned with the question of how to be a Buddhist in the time of decline. The Kamakura period saw the rise of the new Pure Land schools like Jōdo-shū and Jōdo Shinshū founded by Hōnen and Shinran respectively, stressing total reliance on Amitabha Buddha's grace as the only possible solution to the age of decline.

Nichiren Buddhism, founded by Nichiren at around the same time, similarly uses the Dharma decline teaching in an exclusive sense to argue that only its own teaching of Lotus Sutra devotion (through the chanting of the sutra's title, the daimoku) is effective during this era. For Nichiren, the only solution to Dharma decline was for the imperial government to embrace the Lotus Sutra and ban all other Buddhist sects. Only when this was done would Japan become a beacon of Dharma for the world, spreading the true Dharma and reversing the age of decline throughout the whole world.

Some Zen monks such as Dōgen and Xuyun had alternative views regarding dharma decline. Xuyun thought the era of decline is not inevitable. Dōgen fully rejects the theory of Dharma decline, adamantly promoting the practice of zazen as useful at all times. As such, his teaching was in sharp contrast to other Kamakura era Buddhists who promoted the theory of decline.

Saviors of the degenerate age

While the coming of the decline of Dharma and the age of strife is certainly a time which Buddhists looked upon with trepidation, the various narratives also provided some hope. This came in the shape of Buddhist savior figures which could help people through these difficult times.

Relief of Maitreya surrounded by devotees, Kushan or Kidarite, Hadda, Afghanistan.

Traditionally, the most important figure who is held to herald the end of the degenerate age is the future Buddha Maitreya (Pali: Metteya). In both Mahayana and Theravada, devotion to Maitreya and cultivation of meritorious actions is said to help a person be reborn in a place and time that would allow them to meet Maitreya. This could refer to Maitreya's current abode in Maitreya's inner court in Tushita heaven or to the time in the future when Maitreya arrives on earth.

Apart from Maitreya, there are also kingly figures associated with the future chakravartin king who will usher in the future golden age. In some sources, this king is named Sankha and he is seen as someone who will unite the world, rule virtuously and promote virtue. This occurs just before the descent of Maitreya. Tibetan Buddhism, influenced by the Kalacakra Tantra, has a more elaborate mythos, which teaches about a future king named Kalki, who rules a virtuous Buddhist kingdom called Shambala. He is also seen as someone who will defeat non-Buddhist barbaric invaders (mlecchas) in a great war. This myth is likely borrowed from Hindu myths of the Kalki avatar.

In Mahayana, certain other figures are also venerated as saviors who offer guidance, protection, and liberation during the degenerate age. One prominent savior figure is Amitābha Buddha, central to Pure Land Buddhism. Amitābha vowed to create a pure peaceful realm, Sukhāvatī, where beings could be reborn through faith in him. This provides an accessible path to liberation for all, bypassing the challenges of the degenerate age by allowing them to escape this world and be reborn in the pure land. Avalokiteśvara Bodhisattva is also seen as a savior figure, offering immediate assistance to those in distress and physical danger. Kṣitigarbha is also known for his vow to take responsibility for the instruction of all beings in the six worlds, in the era between the death of Gautama and the rise of Maitreya.

In the Lotus Sutra, Viśiṣṭacāritra is entrusted to spread Buddhist dharma in the age of Dharma decline and save mankind and the earth. He and countless other bodhisattvas, specifically called Bodhisattvas of the Earth (of which he is the leader), vow to be reborn in a latter day to re-create Buddhist dharma, thus turning the degenerate age into a flourishing paradise. Gautama Buddha entrusts them instead of his more commonly known major disciples with this task since the Bodhisattvas of the Earth have had a karmic connection with Gautama Buddha since the beginning of time, meaning that they are aware of the Superior Practice which is the essence of Buddhism or the Dharma in its original, pure form.

In other religions

Some Chinese folk religions borrow the idea of the final age of Dharma from Buddhism. Some Chinese religions even teach that the three ages were associated with Buddhist figures like Dīpankara Buddha, Gautama Buddha, and Maitreya. Chinese salvationist religions are particularly focused on this idea, and they often promote themselves as teachings which are just right for the current age of decline since they can provide a path to salvation.

Bibliography

• Buswell, Robert E., ed. (2004). Encyclopedia of Buddhism ("Decline of the Dharma"). Macmillan Reference USA. ISBN 0-02-865718-7. pp. 210-213
• Chappell, David Wellington (1980). Early Forebodings of the Death of Buddhism, Numen, 27 (1), 122-154
• Hattori, Shōon (2000). A Raft from the Other Shore: Honen and the Way of Pure Land Buddhism. Jodo Shu Press. ISBN 978-4-88363-329-6.
• Lamotte, Etienne; Webb-Boin Sara, trans. (1988). History of Indian Buddhism: From the origins to the Śaka era. Louvain Paris: Peters Press, pp. 191-202
• Marra, Michele (1988). "The development of mappō thought in Japan (I)", Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 15 (1), 25-54. PDF
• Marra, Michele (1988). "The development of mappō thought in Japan (II)", Japanese Journal of Religious Studies 15 (4), 287-305. PDF
• Nadeau, Randall L. (1987). "The 'Decline of the Dharma' in Early Chinese Buddhism", Asian Review volume 1 (transl. of the "Scripture Preached by the Buddha on the Total Extinction of the Dharma")
• Nattier, Jan (1991). Once Upon a Future Time: Studies in a Buddhist Prophecy of Decline, Berkeley, Calif.: Asian Humanities Press
• Stone, Jackie (1985). Seeking Enlightenment in the Last Age: "Mappō" Thought in Kamakura Buddhism: PART I, The Eastern Buddhist New Series, 18, (1), 28-56
• Stone, Jackie (1985). Seeking Enlightenment in the Last Age: "Mappō" Thought in Kamakura Buddhism: PART II, The Eastern Buddhist New Series, 18, (2), 35-64
• Zürcher, Eric (1981). Eschatology and Messianism in Early Chinese Buddhism, Leiden: Leyden Studies in Sinology

External links

• The Buddha Speaks the Ultimate Extinction of the Dharma Sutra, The Buddhist Text Translation Society